Digital repository of Slovenian research organisations

Show document
A+ | A- | Help | SLO | ENG

Title:Aerial and respiratory atmospheres of Avicenna's flying person
Authors:ID Berndtson, Petri Joakim (Author)
Files:.pdf PDF - Presentation file, download (180,07 KB)
MD5: 34D126B3799E04968DE7A22B7C24919E
 
URL URL - Source URL, visit https://doi.org/10.35469/poligrafi.2021.292
 
Language:English
Typology:1.01 - Original Scientific Article
Organization:Logo ZRS Koper - Science and Research Centre Koper
Abstract:Persian philosopher Avicenna (980‒1037) is famous for his thought experiment concerning the flying person,” “floating person” or “person suspended in air.” In this thought experiment, a person is created flying in the air in a state of total sensory deprivation. Scholars have debated for centuries what this thought experiment is all about. Most scholars have interpreted this thought experiment as essentially being about the existence of the soul (al-nafs) in its immateriality, substantiality, and self-awareness, as well as about the difference between the soul and the body. In my article, I will interpret Avicenna’s thought experiment in a totally different manner within the atmospheres of air and breathing. In my reading, I will carefully examine the fact neglected by scholars that this flight happens in the air and that it is the air that defines the existence of the flying person. With this aerial attitude I will argue that this thought experiment is not above all about the soul, but about air and al-nafs as a respiratory self. In my aerial and respiratory interpretation of Avicenna’s flying person, I will use Gaston Bachelard’s phenomenologically oriented aerial thinking as well as etymological analysis of al-nafs.
Keywords:flying person, floating person, breathing, air
Publication status:Published
Publication version:Version of Record
Publication date:29.12.2021
Year of publishing:2021
Number of pages:str. 131-151
Numbering:Letn. 26, št. 103/104
PID:20.500.12556/DiRROS-14876 New window
UDC:591.121:13
ISSN on article:1318-8828
DOI:10.35469/poligrafi.2021.292 New window
COBISS.SI-ID:100051971 New window
Copyright:ZRS Koper
Publication date in DiRROS:22.03.2022
Views:448
Downloads:322
Metadata:XML RDF-CHPDL DC-XML DC-RDF
:
Copy citation
  
Share:Bookmark and Share


Hover the mouse pointer over a document title to show the abstract or click on the title to get all document metadata.

Record is a part of a journal

Title:Poligrafi : revija za religiologijo, mitologijo in filozofijo
Shortened title:Poligrafi
Publisher:Nova revija, Društvo za primerjalno religiologijo, Nova revija, Društvo za primerjalno religiologijo, Univerza na Primorskem, Znanstveno-raziskovalno središče, Univerzitetna založba Annales, Društvo za primerjalno religiologijo, Znanstveno-raziskovalno središče, Annales ZRS, Društvo za primerjalno religiologijo
ISSN:1318-8828
COBISS.SI-ID:59336192 New window

Secondary language

Language:English
Abstract:Perzijski filozof Avicena (980‒1037) je znan po svojem miselnem eksperimentu v zvezi z »letečim« ali »lebdečim človekom« oziroma s »človekom, ki visi v zraku«. Ta postulira, da se človek pojavi kakor lebdeč v zraku v stanju popolne senzorne deprivacije. Znanstveniki so stoletja razpravljali o tem, o čem naj bi šlo pri tem poskusu. Večina v njem vidi dokazovanje obstoja duše (al-nafs) v njeni nesnovno-sti, substancialnosti in samozavedanju, pa tudi kot dokazovanje neenakosti med dušo in telesom. avtor v članku razlaga avicenov miselni eksperiment na povsem drugačen način, znotraj atmosfer zraka in dihanja. V svoji interpretaciji podrobno preuči dejstvo, ki ga znanstveniki zanemarjajo, in sicer, da se ta let dogaja v zraku, torej da zrak opredeljuje obstoj letečega človeka. V takšni zračni perspektivi avtor dokazuje, da pri tem miselnem eksperimentu ne gre prvenstveno za dušo, temveč za zrak in al-nafs kot respiratorno sebstvo. V svoji zračni in respiratorni interpretaciji avicenovega letečega človeka uporabi na zrak osredinjeno fenomenološko razmišljanje Gastona Bachelarda in se opre na etimološko analizo izraza al-nafs.
Keywords:Avicena, leteči človek, lebdeči človek, Bachelard, dihanje, zrak, al-nafs


Back