Digitalni repozitorij raziskovalnih organizacij Slovenije

Izpis gradiva
A+ | A- | Pomoč | SLO | ENG

Naslov:Pantheism from the perspective of Wittgensteinian nonoverlapping magisteria (WNOMA)
Avtorji:ID Andrejč, Gorazd (Avtor)
Datoteke:.pdf PDF - Predstavitvena datoteka, prenos (329,64 KB)
MD5: 9BE942E49316A18F55674685C7B23EBA
 
URL URL - Izvorni URL, za dostop obiščite https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/14/12/1551
 
Jezik:Angleški jezik
Tipologija:1.01 - Izvirni znanstveni članek
Organizacija:Logo ZRS Koper - Znanstveno-raziskovalno središče Koper / Centro di Ricerche Scientifiche Capodistria
Povzetek:This essay examines pantheism within the framework of the ‘faith and reason’ field in the philosophy of religion, with an emphasis on the question of the relationship between pantheism and empirical–scientific rationality. I address this question from what I call the Wittgensteinian Nonoverlapping Magisteria (WNOMA) approach to religion and science. WNOMA affirms a categorial difference between religious and scientific language and attitudes. This difference is interpreted with the help of Wittgenstein’s distinction between religious and scientific beliefs and van Fraassen’s distinction between religious and empiricist stances. This means that WNOMA is antievidentialist regarding religious beliefs and sees the experiential and instinctive aspects of religion as more fundamental than the systematic–intellectual aspect. Part of the variety in contemporary pantheism relates to the question of whether the emphasis is on the experiential–spiritual side of pantheism or its intellectual side, i.e., whether pantheism is ‘hot’ or ‘cold’. I examine a few telling examples: Spinoza, Einstein, the World Pantheism Movement and a recent awe-some argument for pantheism by Ryan Byerly. The main contribution of this paper is a critical reading of these versions of pantheism from a WNOMA perspective, through which I hope to establish the plausibility and show some of the persuasive force of the WNOMA approach to pantheism, focusing on the relation of pantheism to scientific rationality on the one hand and felt experience on the other. I argue that hotter kinds of pantheism can be intellectually virtuous if they find a way to combine the empiricist stance and pantheist religious stance, even without a developed philosophical or theological system. I also argue that colder and philosophically rigorous pantheism can be problematic if it assumes religious evidentialism, neglects the experiential part of pantheism in favor of intellectualism or/and confuses the spheres of science and religion.
Ključne besede:pantheism, faith and reason, religion and science, nonoverlapping magisteria
Verzija publikacije:Objavljena publikacija
Poslano v recenzijo:04.12.2024
Datum sprejetja članka:08.12.2024
Datum objave:18.12.2023
Leto izida:2023
Št. strani:21 str.
Številčenje:Vol. 14, iss. 12, [article no.] 1551
PID:20.500.12556/DiRROS-20846 Novo okno
UDK:2-136.6
ISSN pri članku:2077-1444
DOI:10.3390 Novo okno
COBISS.SI-ID:179606531 Novo okno
Avtorske pravice:© 2023 by the author
Opomba:Nasl. z nasl. zaslona; Opis vira z dne 5. 1. 2024;
Datum objave v DiRROS:20.11.2024
Število ogledov:223
Število prenosov:97
Metapodatki:XML DC-XML DC-RDF
:
ANDREJČ, Gorazd, 2023, Pantheism from the perspective of Wittgensteinian nonoverlapping magisteria (WNOMA). Religions [na spletu]. 2023. Vol. 14, no. 12,  1551. [Dostopano 18 april 2025]. DOI 10.3390. Pridobljeno s: https://dirros.openscience.si/IzpisGradiva.php?lang=slv&id=20846
Kopiraj citat
  
Objavi na:Bookmark and Share


Postavite miškin kazalec na naslov za izpis povzetka. Klik na naslov izpiše podrobnosti ali sproži prenos.

Gradivo je del revije

Naslov:Religions
Skrajšan naslov:Religions
Založnik:MDPI AG
ISSN:2077-1444
COBISS.SI-ID:520261657 Novo okno

Gradivo je financirano iz projekta

Financer:ARIS - Javna agencija za znanstvenoraziskovalno in inovacijsko dejavnost Republike Slovenije
Program financ.:Raziskovalni projekti
Številka projekta:J6-1813-2019
Naslov:Ustvarjena bitja, ljudje, roboti: teologija stvarjenja med humanizmom in posthumanizmom

Licence

Licenca:CC BY 4.0, Creative Commons Priznanje avtorstva 4.0 Mednarodna
Povezava:http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.sl
Opis:To je standardna licenca Creative Commons, ki daje uporabnikom največ možnosti za nadaljnjo uporabo dela, pri čemer morajo navesti avtorja.
Začetek licenciranja:18.12.2024

Sekundarni jezik

Jezik:Slovenski jezik
Ključne besede:panteizem, vera in razum, religija in znanost, neprekrivanje magisteria


Nazaj